2005-2006 Winners:
| Date | Athlete | Sport | Date | Athlete | Sport |
| 8/22/05 | Dustin Bainter | Boys Golf | 1/2/06 | Matt Buren | Boys Basketball |
| 8/29/05 | Myers Hendrickston | Football | 1/9/06 | Evan Kline | Wrestling |
| 9/5/05 | Derek Wiley | Football | 1/16/06 | Becca Roberts | Girls Basketball |
| 9/12/05 | Sasha Wicket | Volleyball | 1/23/06 | Michael Thompson | Boys Basketball |
| 9/19/05 | Annie Speer | Girls Tennis | 1/30/06 | Jaclyn Lucas | Girls Basketball |
| 9/26/05 | Ashley Breedeen | Volleyball | 2/6/06 | Curt Myers | Wrestling |
| 10/3/05 | Dane Jorgensen | Boys Soccer | 2/13/06 | Tyler Van Vleet | Boys Basketball |
| 10/10/05 | Kooten Johnson | Football | 2/20/06 | Phillip Moe | Boys Basketball |
| 10/17/05 | Wes Carter | Football | 2/27/06 | Emmett Hall | Wrestling |
| 10/24/05 | Phillip Moe | Boys Cross Country | 3/6/06 | Jesse Kugler | Wrestling |
| 10/31/05 | Brittany Rigdon | Girls Cross Country | 3/13/06 | Derek Wiley | Wrestling |
| 11/7/05 | Katelyn Hillyer | Girls Swimming | 3/20/06 | Wes Carter | Boys Track |
| 11/14/05 | Alayna Colley | Girls Swimming | 3/27/06 | Ben Pratt | Boys Track |
| 11/21/05 | Anna Pumo | Girls Basketball | 4/3/06 | Myers Hendrickson | Baseball |
| 11/28/05 | Dustin Bainter | Boys Basketball | 4/10/06 | Nathan Frantz | Boys Tennis |
| 12/5/05 | Aaron Jones | Wrestling | 4/17/06 | Davis Hendrickson | Baseball |
| 12/12/05 | Lyndi Thorman | Girls Basketball | 4/24/06 | Anne Harris | Girls Soccer |
| 12/19/05 | Josh Murphy | Boys Swimming | 5/1/06 | Janelle Leatherwood | Girls Track |
| 12/26/05 | Katie Gettinger | Girls Basketball | 5/8/06 | Stef Myers | Softball |
| 5/15/06 | LaCresha Miller | Girls Track |
