2000-2001 Winners:
| Date | Athlete | Sport | Date | Athlete | Sport |
| 9/3/00 | Janine Buettner | Volleball | 1/1/01 | Chad Cox | Boys Basketball |
| 9/11/00 | Brent Flickinger | Boys Cross Country | 1/8/01 | Grant Covey | Boys Swimming |
| 9/18/00 | Elizabeth Boomer | Girls Cross Country | 1/15/01 | Kristi Reusch | Girls Basketball |
| 9/25/00 | Blake Bainter | Football | 1/22/01 | Dustin Wiley | Wrestling |
| 10/2/00 | Ryan Moore | Boys Golf | 1/29/01 | Blake Bainter | Boys Basketball |
| 10/9/00 | Pat Raftis | Football | 2/5/01 | Ricci Shryock | Girls Basketball |
| 10/16/00 | Zander DiGrino | Football | 2/12/01 | Josh Montalvo | Boys Swimming |
| 10/23/00 | Bryan Clauson | Boys Cross Country | 2/19/01 | Kelly Nicols | Boys Basketball |
| 10/30/00 | Elizabeth Boomer | Girls Cross Country | 2/26/01 | Rob Strohecker Anthony Sparrow |
Boys Swimming |
| 11/6/00 | Ricky Foster | Boys Cross Country | 3/5/01 | Luke Lunt | Boys Basketball |
| 11/13/00 | Nancy Johnson | Girls Swimming | 3/12/01 | Danny Huges | Boys Basketball |
| 11/20/00 | Amber Moore | Girls Basketball | 3/19/01 | Megan Stoneking | Girls Track |
| 11/27/00 | Luke Lunt | Boys Basketball | 3/26/01 | Kristin Roelle | Softball |
| 12/4/00 | Zack Pittman | Wrestling | 4/9/01 | Blaake Bainter | Baseball |
| 12/11/00 | Chris Choten | Wrestling | 4/16/01 | Adam Hainline | Boys Track |
| 12/18/00 | MOTHER NATURE | n/a | 4/23/01 | Jessica Throman | Softball |
| 12/25/00 | Tanner Scott | Boys Basketball | 4/30/01 | Jeff Hart | Boys Tennis |
| 5/7/01 | Tanner Scott | Baseball | |||
| 5/14/01 | Kristi Reusch | Softball | |||
| 5/21/01 | Derek Roe | Boys Tennis |
